4 – Management of Employees’ Performance

Managing the performance of employees is an important aspect of any organisation. It involves setting clear expectations for job performance, providing regular feedback, and taking action to address any deficiencies or areas for improvement. Organisations can improve productivity, increase employee satisfaction, and ultimately drive overall business success by effectively managing performance. A good performance management system should focus on individual and team performance and include regular check-ins and performance evaluations. The goal is to provide employees with a clear understanding of their responsibilities and the standards to which they are held and to give them the support and resources they need to succeed. It also provides the management with the information they need to identify any problems and take steps to address them promptly and effectively.

The management of employees

Providing employees with the necessary information, resources, and mentoring is essential for helping them meet their targets, objectives, and quality standards. This is because it ensures that employees have the knowledge and tools they need to perform their jobs effectively and provides them with guidance and support in achieving their goals.

Information is necessary for employees to understand their roles, responsibilities and what is expected of them. This information can be in job descriptions, training materials, or documentation. By providing employees with the right information, they can better understand their tasks and how they contribute to the organisation’s overall success.

Resources are also important as they allow employees to perform their jobs efficiently and effectively. These can include tools and equipment, technology, and financial resources. Without the necessary resources, employees may struggle to complete their tasks and meet quality standards.

Mentoring or coaching can help employees improve their performance and reach their goals. It provides employees with guidance, advice, and support, and it can also help them develop new skills and knowledge. A good mentor can help employees navigate any challenges they may encounter on the job and help them take steps to overcome them. This guidance can help the employees in self-improvement, help them understand the best practices and, in a way, help the betterment of the organisation.

By providing employees with the right information, resources, and mentoring, organisations can help them meet their targets, objectives, and quality standards, by making sure that they have the knowledge, tools and guidance they need to perform their jobs effectively, which helps them meet the goals of the organisation. In turn, it will drive the overall success of the organisation.

Methods to monitor progress

Several methods can be used to monitor employees’ progress towards their objectives according to agreed plans. These methods can include:

1. Performance appraisals: Performance appraisals are commonly used to evaluate an employee’s job performance. These evaluations typically involve a review of an employee’s work over a specific period, such as a year, and are usually conducted by the employee’s manager or supervisor. The appraisal process should include a review of the employee’s objectives and plans and an assessment of their progress towards achieving them.
2. Key Performance Indicators (KPIs): KPIs are a set of measurable values that organisations use to track and evaluate the performance of their employees. They can be used to track progress towards specific objectives and can be tailored to align with the organisation’s goals.
3. Progress reports: Progress reports are used to track and communicate an employee’s progress towards their objectives. These reports can be used to document progress over time and can be shared with the employee’s manager or supervisor.
4. Self-evaluations: Self-evaluations allow employees to assess their progress and performance. These evaluations can provide valuable feedback to managers and supervisors and help employees identify improvement areas.
5. Peer evaluations: Peer evaluations allow employees to provide feedback to their colleagues on their performance. This can be beneficial as it can provide a different perspective on an employee’s performance and help identify areas for improvement that a manager or supervisor may not have identified.
6. Scorecard or Dashboard: Scorecards and dashboards are used as a visual representation of performance metrics, usually showing the progress of the performance metrics, goal, and current status.

These methods can be used individually or in combination, and the choice will depend on the organisation’s specific needs and goals. It is also important to involve employees in the process and discuss their progress and any challenges they face; this will enable them to take ownership of their progress and work together with their managers to achieve the objectives.

Recognising achievement

Recognising individuals’ achievement of targets and quality standards is important for several reasons:

1. It helps to motivate employees: Recognising employees for their achievements can help to boost morale and motivation by providing positive reinforcement for a job well done. This motivation will then lead to better performance and increased productivity.
2. It helps to build a positive work culture: Recognising employees for their achievements can help to create a positive work culture in which employees feel valued and appreciated. This can lead to increased job satisfaction and employee engagement.
3. It helps to identify high performers: Recognising employees for their achievements can help identify high performers who can be recognised and rewarded for their contributions to the organisation. This can also set an example to other employees, encouraging them to strive for similar achievements.
4. It helps to keep employees accountable: Recognising their achievements also allows organisations to hold them accountable for their performance, as they know that their achievements are being tracked, monitored and recognised.
5. It helps to improve performance: Recognising and rewarding employees for their achievements can help to improve performance by providing incentives for employees to meet and exceed targets and quality standards.

Recognition can take many forms, from verbal acknowledgement to written and formal awards, bonuses, and even promotions, it’s important to note that it should be timely, specific, and sincere. By providing regular recognition, organisations can show their employees that they value their hard work and contributions, which can help to build a more productive, engaged, and satisfied workforce.

The management of underperformance in the workplace

Managing underperformance in the workplace is an important aspect of performance management. It involves identifying and addressing employee work performance deficiencies that fall short of the agreed-upon standards and expectations. Organisations can effectively manage underperformance, improve productivity, maintain high-quality standards, and create a positive work environment. A good performance management system should include regular check-ins and performance evaluations, focusing on addressing any underperformance issues in a timely and constructive manner. The goal is to provide employees with clear feedback and support to help them improve their performance and meet the standards required by the organisation. In addition to addressing underperformance, it is important to recognise and reward good performance; this ensures that the performance management program is not solely focused on negative aspects but is a holistic approach to managing employee performance.

Policies and procedures

Organisations typically have policies and procedures for underperformance, discipline, and grievances. These policies and procedures can vary between organisations, but they generally include the following steps:

1. Identification of underperformance: The first step in dealing with underperformance is to identify it. This can be done through regular check-ins and performance evaluations, where managers or supervisors assess an employee’s performance against agreed-upon standards and expectations.
2. Communication and feedback: Once underperformance has been identified, it is important to communicate it to the employee and provide feedback on their performance. This feedback should be specific, objective, and focused on areas where the employee falls short.
3. Performance improvement plan: A Performance Improvement Plan (PIP) may be developed if an employee’s performance is under par. This plan outlines specific goals, timelines and actions for employees to improve their performance.
4. Monitoring and follow-up: Regular monitoring of the employee’s performance is essential to ensure that the PIP is being followed and that progress is being made. Follow-up meetings are conducted to review progress and make any necessary adjustments.
5. Discipline: If employees fail to improve their performance despite the PIP, disciplinary action may be taken. This can include verbal or written warnings, suspension, demotion or termination of employment, the nature of the disciplinary action will depend on the severity and frequency of the underperformance.
6. Grievance: A grievance procedure may be used if an employee has a complaint or dispute about their performance. Grievance procedures usually involve a process for employees to raise their concerns, usually with their supervisor or manager first and then with a higher level of management if the issue is not resolved.
7. Due Process: All the steps are followed with due process, ensuring that the employee is aware of the specific concerns and allowed to respond and provide their perspective. The employee can also appeal the decision if they disagree with it.

It’s important to note that these policies and procedures should be communicated to employees and accessible to all; they should be regularly reviewed and updated as needed. They should also be fair and consistent in the application and should be used as a last resort when other interventions have not been successful in addressing underperformance.

Following processes

Following disciplinary and grievance processes is important for several reasons:

1. It ensures fairness: By following disciplinary and grievance processes, organisations can ensure that their employees are treated fairly and that any concerns or issues are addressed consistently and impartially. It also ensures that the employee is aware of the specific concerns and allowed to respond and provide their perspective.
2. It promotes trust: Following disciplinary and grievance processes promotes trust between employees and management by providing employees with a clear process for raising concerns or issues and a fair and impartial process for addressing them.
3. It helps maintain a positive work environment: Following disciplinary and grievance processes helps to maintain a positive work environment by addressing any underperformance or workplace concerns quickly and effectively. This promotes a culture of fairness and respect, where employees feel valued and supported.
4. It helps to prevent legal disputes: Failure to follow disciplinary and grievance processes can lead to legal disputes, as employees may feel that their rights have been violated. By following these processes, organisations can reduce the risk of legal disputes and provide a clear defence if any claims are made.
5. It helps to maintain productivity: By following disciplinary and grievance processes, organisations can promptly address underperformance and workplace concerns, preventing the issue from affecting their overall productivity.
6. It helps to retain employees: By following disciplinary and grievance processes, organisations can help to retain employees by addressing issues of underperformance and workplace concerns fairly and respectfully. This can lead to increased job satisfaction and employee engagement.

Disciplinary and grievance processes must be followed as they help ensure fairness, promote trust, maintain a positive work environment, prevent legal disputes and contribute to the retention of employees, which helps the organisation’s smooth running and improves overall performance.

Causes of underperformance

Identifying the causes of underperformance can be challenging, as there can be various reasons for an employee’s performance falling short of expectations. Some common causes of underperformance include:

1. Lack of skill or knowledge: Employees may be underperforming because they lack the skills or knowledge necessary to perform their job effectively. This can be due to a lack of proper training or development opportunities.
2. Poorly defined expectations or goals: An employee may be underperforming if they do not understand the expectations or goals of their role or if these expectations or goals are not clearly defined.
3. Unclear communication or lack of support: Employees may be underperforming if they do not receive clear communication or adequate support from their manager or supervisor. This can make it difficult for them to understand their responsibilities and perform their job effectively.
4. Personal issues: Personal issues such as stress, health concerns or family problems can affect an employee’s performance.
5. Lack of motivation or engagement: Employees may be underperforming if they lack motivation or engagement in their job. This can be caused by a lack of recognition or rewards for good performance or by a lack of opportunities for growth and development.
6. Workplace issues: An employee may be underperforming if there are issues with their work environment, such as poor management, conflicts with colleagues, or a lack of resources.
7. Organisational changes: An employee may be underperforming due to changes in the organisation, such as changes in strategy, systems, or processes that are not communicated or supported.

To identify the causes of underperformance, it’s important to gather information from various sources, including performance evaluations, regular check-ins, employee feedback and observation; this can be done individually or through team assessments. This can help to get a clear and accurate picture of the employee’s performance and the reasons behind any deficiencies. Once the causes of underperformance are identified, appropriate interventions can be implemented to address them, such as providing training or development opportunities, improving communication or support, or addressing any workplace issues affecting performance.

Informing employees of underperformance

The purpose of making individuals aware of their underperformance clearly but sensitively is to help them understand the areas where their performance is falling short and to provide them with the opportunity to improve. It’s important to communicate underperformance clearly and specifically, but also sensitively, to ensure that the employee understands the concerns but also to not demotivate or discourage them.

Communicating underperformance in a clear but sensitive manner can help to:

1. Improve performance: By making employees aware of their underperformance and providing them with specific feedback, they will understand what they need to improve on and take steps to address the issues.
2. Maintain morale and motivation: Sensitively communicating underperformance can help to maintain an employee’s morale and motivation. When employees receive critical feedback respectfully, they are more likely to take it as constructive and act on it; this helps them to improve their performance.
3. Build trust and engagement: Communicating underperformance in a clear but sensitive manner can help to build trust and engagement between employees and management. When employees feel that their performance is being evaluated fairly and objectively and that their contributions are valued, they are more likely to feel engaged and motivated to improve their performance.
4. Avoid unnecessary conflict: Communicating underperformance in a sensitive manner can help to avoid unnecessary conflict, by addressing performance issues as soon as they arise, employees will be less likely to feel resentful or defensive and more likely to take the feedback positively and make the necessary improvements.
5. Prevent the situation from escalating: Communicating underperformance clearly and sensitively can help prevent the situation from escalating, leading to more serious consequences such as legal disputes, bad morale, and low productivity.

The purpose of making individuals aware of their underperformance clearly but sensitively is to address performance issues in a timely and effective manner and help employees improve their performance in a way that also maintains their morale and motivation, which ultimately benefits both the employee and the organisation.

Addressing issues

Addressing issues that hamper an individual’s performance can be done in several ways:

1. Providing training and development opportunities: One of the most effective ways to address issues that hamper an individual’s performance is to provide training and development opportunities that can help the employee acquire the skills and knowledge necessary to perform their job effectively.
2. Improving communication and support: Improving communication and support can help to address issues such as unclear expectations or goals or a lack of support from a manager or supervisor. By providing clear, regular communication and providing adequate support, employees will be better able to understand their responsibilities and perform their job effectively.
3. Addressing personal issues: If an employee’s performance is being hampered by personal issues such as stress, health concerns, or family problems, it is important to provide them with the support they need to address these issues, whether it is through an Employee assistance programme, counselling, or time off.
4. Recognising and rewarding good performance: Recognising and rewarding good performance can help to address issues such as a lack of motivation or engagement by providing employees with positive reinforcement for a job well done. This helps to motivate employees and also helps them to see that good performance is appreciated and is being recognised.
5. Addressing workplace issues: Addressing issues such as conflicts with colleagues or a poor work environment can help to improve employee performance. By addressing these issues, employees will be more likely to feel satisfied and engaged in their work, leading to better performance.
6. Addressing organisational changes: If performance issues are related to organisational changes, such as changes in strategy, systems or processes, it is important to provide employees with the support they need to adapt to these changes and help them understand the rationale behind the change.
7. Performance Improvement Plan(PIP): Developing a Performance Improvement Plan (PIP) can effectively address an individual’s underperformance. A PIP is a written plan outlining specific goals, timelines, and actions for the employee to take to improve their performance; monitoring and follow-up meetings are also scheduled to review progress and make any necessary adjustments.

It’s important to remember that addressing performance issues is a process and not an event; it’s important to have regular check-ins and follow-ups, continuously monitor the employee’s progress, and adjust the plan as needed. And for the employee to take ownership and be invested in the process, it’s important to involve them in the process and discuss their progress and any challenges they are facing.

An agreed course of action

Agreeing on a course of action to address underperformance can involve several steps:

1. Identify the specific areas of underperformance: Before agreeing on a course of action, it’s important to identify the areas where the employee’s performance falls short. This can be done through regular check-ins, performance evaluations, and employee feedback.
2. Discuss the performance issues with the employee: Once the areas of underperformance have been identified, it’s important to discuss them with the employee. The discussion should focus on specific issues and be objective and non-judgmental. The employee should be allowed to provide their perspective on the performance issues.
3. Identify the causes of underperformance: During the discussion, it’s important to identify the underlying causes. This could be due to a lack of skill or knowledge, unclear expectations or goals, personal issues, lack of motivation or engagement, workplace issues, or organisational changes.
4. Develop a Performance Improvement Plan (PIP): Based on the identified causes of underperformance, a Performance Improvement Plan (PIP) can be developed. This plan should outline specific goals, timelines, and actions for the employee to take to improve their performance. The employee should be involved in the development of the plan and should understand the expectations and goals.
5. Agree on a course of action: Once the PIP has been developed, the employee and manager should agree to address the underperformance. The agreed course of action should include clear timelines, specific goals, and actions to be taken by the employee, manager and the organisation.
6. Monitor and follow-up: It’s important to monitor the employee’s progress and follow up regularly to assess the effectiveness of the PIP and make any necessary adjustments. Follow-up meetings should be scheduled to review progress, identify challenges, and provide additional support.
7. Recognise and reward good performance: It’s important to recognise and reward good performance; this helps to maintain the employee’s morale, motivation, and engagement.

Overall, agreeing on a course of action to address underperformance is a collaborative process involving the employee and the manager, and should be based on clear and specific feedback, identification of the underlying causes of underperformance, and agreement on a particular plan of action to improve performance. Regular follow-up and monitoring are essential to ensure that progress is being made and adjustments are made as needed.

Test your knowledge